So Dat’s Dat!

After ten years, ten months and ten days in office, Bertie’s finally gone! You cannot but wonder if Mary Harney will soon be following him. Brian Cowen, our Taoiseach-in-waiting, is due to receive his seal of office tomorrow and will announce his new cabinet shortly afterwards. Will he show Mary the door?

I had to laugh when reading about the HSE in the Sunday Indo yesterday. “A bloated system”. “HSE belt tightening is a fat lot of good”. “The HSE like everyone else needs to tighten the belt, to cut a little fat”. “The HSE will soon resemble a hippopotamus in bondage gear”. I”ll give you one guess as to what stimulates this sort of language from newspaper columnists. You’re right! Our present Minister for Health is no advert for healthy living and after three and a half years in the job, she’s definitely looking the worse for wear. Harney took on this role in September 2004 with promises to reform the health service. During her time in office, she is credited with achieving a reduction in A&E waiting times, putting a new cancer control programme in place, reducing operation waiting times and the introduction of hygiene audits.

A recent report provided by the HSE, showed that in the first two months of this year 44 per cent of patients in hospital emergency departments awaiting admission, had to wait longer than the official maximum target period of 12 hours. The report also revealed that the number of patients waiting more than 24 hours for admission increased by 57 per cent over the same period last year. The only thing that has improved is the HSE’s daily fiddling of the figures to make it look like there is a reduction in the numbers on trolleys.

As regards the cancer control programme, Mary Harney secured at enormous cost, the appointment of a top cancer specialist, Prof Tom Keane. His mission is to restructure cancer care in this country with the introduction of 8 new centres of excellence. According to John Crown, a medical oncologist, none of the four centres planned for Dublin will be comprehensive. “The plan is that colon cancer is treated in one place, lung cancer in some other place. That is not excellence in care. It is a system based on compromises which are in turn based on medical politics”. Under the new plan, there will be no centre of excellence located north of a line between Dublin and Galway. This system is already doomed to failure.

Waiting lists for operations have been reduced but at a huge cost. Surgeons and their operating teams in our public health system are frequently left twiddling their thumbs when their operating lists are cancelled because of the shortage of beds for elective admissions. Meanwhile the HSE is paying top dollars to the private hospitals via the National Treatment Private Fund (NTPF) to have public patients treated in the private system. This madness is Mary’s solution to the long waiting lists. Talk about false economy.

And finally the hygiene audits. Mary Harney promised back in 2005, to tackle health care associated infections (HCAI) and said that the target over the next three to five years would be to reduce hospital-acquired infections by 20 per cent and MRSA by 30 per cent. The numbers of patients becoming infected with MRSA fell only slightly last year. Newly released figures show there were 533 cases of bloodstream MRSA infection reported last year, compared with 588 in 2006, a reduction of less than 10 per cent. Overcrowding, poor cleaning, haphazard hand hygiene, infrastructural defects, and lack of infection-control staff particularly microbiologists, is favouring the spread of the hospital superbugs. Our Minister for Health is more interested in budget control than infection control and patients remain at serious risk of infection.

New official figures have shown that the HSE is now €95 million over budget for the first four months of the year. The HSE has drawn up a series of controversial proposals to claw back on the financial overrun. These include hospital bed closures, the curtailment of A&E services and new restrictions on the issuing of medical cards and drug-cost reimbursements. There is also a proposal to divert the €185 million earmarked for the development of services for the disabled, older people and those in palliative care. We ain’t seen nothing yet in terms of cutbacks and the impact this will have on patient care.

There is increasing unrest amongst those working in the health service and patients too, are fast losing patience. Mary Harney’s credibility has been badly damaged by a series of cock-ups and system failures during her tenure in office. The failure to get the new consultant’s contract up and running has been a major blow to her plans. Her promises to reform the health service, have not materialised. The question remains. Will Brian Cowen take the easy route and leave Mary Harney to continue to take the flak or will he have the courage to show her the door?

11 Responses to So Dat’s Dat!

  1. Baino says:

    Wahey . .first on the list. The thing is this Steph, she’s had some ‘time’ in the job. She’s a politician advised by public servants in a “Yes Minister” environment (believe me I worked for the Police Minister for 5 years) Her leaving may not be the answer. Is there anyone more capable of the position? Our previous Minister for Health was at least a Doctor and understood the situation, some changes were made, he wasn’t great but at least he had an understanding of the portfolio. Our current Minister of Health is a Lawyer . . she is advised by public servants. I believe that senior public servants in the system should also be held accountable to the same degree as the Ministers they advise. Sack the Minister, review the ministry. Sorry, feeling a bit bolshy about fat cats on high salaries who watch Ministers come and go and yet do nothing proactive on their behalf. *stomps off to make dinner*

  2. Steph says:

    Well done! Baino

    You’re spot on as always and I love it when your bolshy!

    Harney’s had her chance and she’s failed. Her ideology is so wrong it’s painful and I think the fat cats in the HSE can be held responsible for this. The head of the HSE, Brendan Drumm is a highly respected consultant paediatrician but he too is being led by the bureaucrats. No, it’s time for change. We need a total revamp of the HSE and a complete re-think on the way forward for the health service. While Harney knows the ropes of the job, she’s not likely to backtrack. She has to go.

    btw If you hadn’t realised, the post title is a piss-take at Bertie’s diction 😀

  3. Grannymar says:

    Steph you need someone strong enough with vision to start again with a clean sheet. Excuse pun!

  4. Steph says:


    What I need right now is a stiff drink having just watched ‘herself’ on the news receiving her new Seal of Office from the President. It was some sight, believe me.

    I honestly think, it’s only a matter of time before she’ll be forced to resign. But she won’t go unless she’s pushed. Now if only I had a JCB…

  5. Ian says:

    Cowen’s changes were interesting – a shift away from Dublin? Hanafin was demoted, Tom Kitt was thrown out.

    I don’t think he will reshuffle gain for two years

  6. Steph says:

    I would agree, Ian but one more scandal in the health service could be enough to change that!

  7. I reckon with a bit of leadership …. we Irish would all row in and tighten our belts for the greater good of the country ….. for a bit of leadership!

    I hope Cowen cleans up politics and works on eradicating the ‘money is God’ image that we seem to have as a nation.

    An appointment is on the cards for my knees …. let’s see where that takes me in the Health Service.

    A visit to my GP ….. for a quick feel of my knees cost me €50 today thank you.

    And my knees still wobble! 🙂

  8. Steph says:


    I’d have felt your knees for nuttin’ any time! 😉

    Believe me, what you need is a good Physio. Been there, got the teeshirt!

  9. Joe says:

    Hi Steph, just found your page. Very interesting reading. I have set up a group on Facebook to bring attention to some of the hypocrisy and stupidity of the current health service. Any chance I could put in a link to ‘The Biopsy Report’?? The group is called “Hands off, Harney”! (Feel free to join and spread the word-the more the merrier, and the more influential!)


  10. Steph says:

    Hi! Joe

    Link away! And thanks for asking.

    Anything that helps to bring a bit of logic to Harney’s failed ideology, is fine with me.

  11. […] Source __________________ Did you ever wake up to find, a day that broke up your mind, destroyed your notion of circular time? […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: